Skip to main content
Advocate Wealth Solutions home

July 30, 2025Reviewed October 20266 min read

The 4% Rule in Retirement: Is It Still Valid?

By Gregory S. DuPont, JD, CFP

The 4% rule says to withdraw 4% of your portfolio in the first year of retirement, then adjust that dollar amount for inflation each year. It comes from 1990s historical research by Bill Bengen (opens a separate site in a new tab), which tested 30-year retirements. It is a useful benchmark, not a plan, and it may not fit your accounts, taxes, or timeline.

Common advice, as Gregory S. DuPont, JD, CFP describes it, has been: "Just withdraw 4% of your portfolio each year and you'll never run out of money." In Episode 50 of the March to a Million podcast (opens a separate site in a new tab), he explains why that rule of thumb is not a plan, and why relying on it without deeper thinking can leave a household exposed.

Where did the 4% rule come from?

The rule traces to a study published in the October 1994 Journal of Financial Planning. Bill Bengen tested withdrawal rates against historical market returns (opens a separate site in a new tab) to find a "safe" starting number. For the historical periods he tested, a retiree with a balanced portfolio who withdrew about 4% in the first year, then adjusted that amount for inflation, would have made the money last about 30 years.

Those results describe the past. They do not predict what any future retiree will experience.

How does the 4% rule work in practice?

Here is a hypothetical example using round numbers.

  • Starting point: a $1,000,000 portfolio on the day you retire.
  • Year 1: 4% of $1,000,000 is $40,000.
  • Year 2: if inflation were 3%, you would raise the withdrawal to $41,200.
  • Year 3: if inflation were 3% again, you would raise it to $42,436.

The dollar amount follows inflation, not the portfolio. It does not shrink after a down year in the markets. That is the feature that makes the rule simple, and it is also where the risk sits: a market downturn early in retirement can permanently reduce how long savings last, even when long-term average returns look fine.

Hypothetical example for illustration only. It assumes no taxes, no fees, and no change in spending, and it does not predict or promise any investment return. Actual results will differ.

Is the 4% rule still valid?

It may still be a reasonable starting point for a conversation, but it is not a guarantee. Today's retirees may face conditions that differ from the historical periods the research tested:

  • Market returns and volatility that may not resemble the past
  • Longer retirements, since many households plan for more than 30 years
  • Inflation that does not rise smoothly or predictably
  • Taxes and advisory fees, which a simple withdrawal percentage does not subtract

Researchers update their estimates over time. Morningstar's State of Retirement Income report for 2026 (opens a separate site in a new tab) says retirees can withdraw as much as 3.9% in 2026, and that the figure may be higher or lower depending on strategy and spending assumptions (Morningstar page as read October 16, 2026). Estimates like this are general research, not personalized to any household.

How do taxes and fees change the real number?

The 4% figure is a gross withdrawal. What you can spend is what remains after taxes and fees. Greg DuPont put it this way on the podcast:

"If you're paying a 1% advisory fee, your 4% rule is really a 3% rule. And that's before taxes." (Greg DuPont, on the podcast)

Withdrawals from pre-tax accounts such as a 401(k) or traditional IRA are generally taxed as ordinary income. As a hypothetical, a $40,000 withdrawal taxed at a flat 20% would leave $32,000 to spend. Your own rate depends on your other income, deductions, and the tax law in effect in each year, and you should confirm it with your tax professional.

Hypothetical example for illustration only. It is not tax advice and does not reflect any specific tax situation.

What can a withdrawal plan include beyond a percentage?

The biggest issue is treating the 4% rule like a strategy when it is really a benchmark. A plan built around your own situation may coordinate several decisions, each with trade-offs:

  • Spending flexibility. Spending less after a down market year may help savings last longer. The trade-off is that your lifestyle has to be able to flex.
  • Withdrawal order. The order in which you draw from taxable, tax-deferred, and Roth accounts can change the total tax paid over a retirement. The right order depends on your brackets and on tax rules that can change.
  • Social Security timing. The age you claim affects your monthly benefit and what a surviving spouse receives. Waiting can raise the benefit, but you may need to draw more from savings in the meantime.
  • Essential and discretionary spending. Covering essential expenses with income that does not depend on markets can make a bad year easier to absorb. Guarantees from insurance-based income depend on the insurer's claims-paying ability and usually reduce liquidity.
  • Medical costs later in life. Health care costs can rise as you age and are difficult to predict, so a plan may set money aside for them.

Our retirement income planning work looks at these pieces together, because decisions made in isolation can work against each other.

What do you actually need your money to do?

Instead of defaulting to 4%, start with a different question: What do you actually need your money to do?

From there, an advisor can walk you through strategies that separate needs from wants and allow flexibility in how the rest is invested. We have built out a white paper on this topic (opens a separate site in a new tab), including:

  • The evolution of the 4% rule and its assumptions
  • Key withdrawal strategies (guardrails, buckets, annuities, variable spending)

No single strategy fits everyone, because goals, risks, and circumstances vary widely. Market conditions, inflation, and unexpected expenses can create challenges, and a plan may need adjustments over time.

Where should you start?

The 4% rule is a benchmark, not a plan. A plan built around your own accounts, taxes, and goals may serve you better.

A Clarity Map Session is a 30-minute, no-cost, no-obligation consultation where we look at how your income, taxes, and documents fit together. You can also reach our office at 614-408-0004 for a second opinion.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 4% rule in retirement?

The 4% rule is a guideline for retirement withdrawals. You withdraw 4% of your portfolio in the first year, then raise that dollar amount each year with inflation. It was drawn from historical research on 30-year retirements and is a benchmark, not a plan for your own situation.

Is the 4% rule still valid?

It may still be a useful starting point, but it is not a guarantee. It was built on historical data, and it does not account for your taxes, fees, spending changes, or a retirement longer than 30 years. Morningstar's 2026 research, for example, puts its estimate at as much as 3.9% (as read October 16, 2026), and that figure depends on assumptions.

How long will money last using the 4% rule?

In the historical periods Bengen tested, the rule would have lasted about 30 years. That is not a promise for the future. A market decline early in retirement, higher inflation, higher spending, or a longer life could shorten how long your money lasts.

What are the downsides of the 4% rule?

It uses one fixed pattern for everyone: the same percentage, the same inflation adjustment, and an assumed 30-year retirement. It does not account for taxes, fees, Social Security timing, or health care costs. It also does not change when markets fall, which can raise the risk of drawing down savings too quickly.

Does the 4% rule include taxes and fees?

No, the rule itself is a gross withdrawal figure. Taxes on pre-tax accounts and advisory fees reduce what you can spend. A plan can estimate both for your accounts, and your tax professional can confirm the tax side.

Published July 30, 2025. Reviewed October 2026. Tax law, contribution limits and thresholds change, so read any figure here as of its stated date. None of it is advice about your own situation. Advocate Wealth Solutions is a fee-based planning firm in Dublin, Ohio, and a Clarity Map Session is where questions about your own accounts get answered.

Start here

Find out what a coordinated plan would actually change.

Start with a Clarity Map Session. It costs nothing, it carries no obligation, and you leave knowing where you stand either way.

30 minutes · No cost · No obligation